Eyebrow pencil ranking – the best eyebrow pencils of 2024

Since a good eyebrow pencil makes creating your dream styling easier and the effects more durable, it's good to put on well-proven and effective eyebrow pencils. Filled and dense fluffy brows currently on the top, but even if you prefer delicate styling, a good pencil will help hide bald spots and give a deeper shade. When choosing eyebrow pencils, it is worth paying attention to the shade, pigmentation and texture. Some pencils are too hard and the application may be unpleasant, while too soft tip will be imprecise. We checked some popular eyebrow pencils with a view to these criteria and developed a ranking of the best ones. Check and see which one is your most preferred eyebrow pencil.

The best eyebrow pencils – reviews

Nutridome, Eyebrow pencil with brush and precision tip

Effects 9.8
Quality 9.6
Price 8.7
Pigmentation 10
Hardness 9.4
Efficiency 9.9
Composition 10
Average Rating: 4.82, 2858 votes

Editorial Text:

The Nutridome eyebrow pencil stole the hearts of our testers from the very first use! 💪 The tested option is a Graphite shade of a nice and deep colour. This lets you get a great effect of precise make-up 👩🏻‍ . The testers appreciated also the pencil tip, which makes it easier to apply it exactly where we want 👌. The attached brush easily combs the eyebrow hair and facilitates getting the desired contour. The texture of the pencil is creamy and allows easy application 😊. We must also praise the durability, because the cosmetic is long-lasting, so you do not have to worry about your make-up during the day. The formula contains castor oil and natural candelilla and carnauba waxes, which add to the condition of the eyebrows 🌿 . Nutridome eyebrow pencil is an absolute hit that has proven itself great 🥰.

Benefits

Nutridome, Eyebrow pencil with brush and precision tip

  • nice, deep shade
  • extreme durability
  • optimal texture
  • contains natural waxes
  • high efficiency
  • precision tip
  • ergonomic brush
  • requires no sharpening

Disadvantages

Nutridome, Eyebrow pencil with brush and precision tip

  • available only in the app or at Nutridome website

Golden Rose, Longstay, eyebrow pencil

Effects 8.5
Quality 8.4
Price 7.1
Pigmentation 8.7
Hardness 6.8
Efficiency 6.9
Composition 8.8
Average Rating: 3.95, 1633 votes

Editorial Text:

The Golden Rose brand requires no presentation. It is a manufacturer of make-up cosmetics, whose products enjoy continuous high popularity. We took a closer look at the precision liner in 105 variant, which is a warm, brown shade. The Golden Rose eyebrow pencil performed well in our tests 👍. The precision of the application and the pencil shade deserve praise. The pencil itself was a bit too hard for some testers 😞. The biggest drawback is durability. Despite the cosmetic is called Longstay, in reality the Golden Rose eyebrow pencil wears off far too quickly ⌛. The visual effects are ok, but this is not a product that will ensure permanent make-up for the whole evening.

Benefits

Golden Rose, Longstay, eyebrow pencil

  • aesthetic colour
  • precision tip
  • easy application

Disadvantages

Golden Rose, Longstay, eyebrow pencil

  • poor durability
  • relatively high price
  • a bit too hard for some

Catrice, Eye Brow Stylist, eyebrow pencil

Effects 7.3
Quality 7.1
Price 8.5
Pigmentation 8.4
Hardness 7.5
Efficiency 8.4
Composition 7.6
Average Rating: 3.92, 1021 votes

Editorial Text:

Catrice Eye Brow Stylist eyebrow pencil is another proposal that our testers have checked in practice. For ranking purposes, we chose 020 Date With Ash-ton, a cool brown with medium saturation. The colour is nice and the pigmentation level is sufficient 👌. The pencil itself is classic and requires the use of a standard sharpener. The tip contains a brush in the form of a spiral, which is used to model the eyebrows and comb out excess colour. Durability is good, the colour lasts long enough 👍. Catrice eyebrow pencil is quite efficient, yet on the other hand its volume is small. The attached brush tends to collect too much product 😓. All this makes Catrice Eye Brow Stylist not very efficient.

Benefits

Catrice, Eye Brow Stylist, eyebrow pencil

  • high efficiency
  • moderate price
  • nice pigmentation

Disadvantages

Catrice, Eye Brow Stylist, eyebrow pencil

  • small volume
  • requires sharpening
  • brush collects too much product

Wibo, Eyebrow Pencil, eyebrow pencil

Effects 7.9
Quality 7.3
Price 8
Pigmentation 7.6
Hardness 7.5
Efficiency 6.7
Composition 7.1
Average Rating: 3.72, 680 votes

Editorial Text:

Eyebrow Pencil is the product by Wibo – a brand specializing in make-up cosmetics. For our tests, we chose brown shade No. 2 in a warm colour. The testers had mixed feelings. On the one hand, the Wibo eyebrow pencil has a nice and durable colour, which deserves praise 🙂. On the other hand, the tip of the applicator has an unusual shape and it is difficult to achieve sufficient precision. In addition, the cartridge tends to break, which shortens the product lifetime 😞. The price is moderate, so if are a patient person with a steady hand, this can be a good offer at an affordable price.

Benefits

Wibo, Eyebrow Pencil, eyebrow pencil

  • good durability
  • nice shade
  • moderate price

Disadvantages

Wibo, Eyebrow Pencil, eyebrow pencil

  • cartridge may break
  • relatively inconvenient tip
  • a bit too soft

Eveline, Micro Precise Brow Pencil, eyebrow pencil

Effects 7.4
Quality 7.2
Price 8.8
Pigmentation 7.7
Hardness 6.9
Efficiency 6.8
Composition 6.5
Average Rating: 3.67, 476 votes

Editorial Text:

The Eveline Precise Brow Pencil is distinguished by an extremely thin applicator that enables precise drawing of individual lines of similar thickness to natural eyebrow hair. Our testers praised this effect, although it requires high precision of movements and without proper practice it can be difficult to achieve satisfactory results 🤔. The Eveline eyebrow pencil in the 03 Dark Brown variant has a deep, nice shade of brown. The downside is a delicate cartridge. Dropping the pencil often results in breaking the cartridge 😓. Unfortunately, the Eveline pencil smudges quite quickly, so durability is definitely not its strength. The low price compensates for the relatively low grammage, but after all we cannot call it the best pencil in its category 😉.

Benefits

Eveline, Micro Precise Brow Pencil, eyebrow pencil

  • precision tip
  • nice, deep shade
  • good brush

Disadvantages

Eveline, Micro Precise Brow Pencil, eyebrow pencil

  • brittle cartridge
  • requires proficiency
  • average durability
  • low grammage

Eyebrow pencil ranking – the best eyebrow pencils of 2024 Eyebrow pencil ranking – the best eyebrow pencils of 2024 Eyebrow pencil ranking – the best eyebrow pencils of 2024 Eyebrow pencil ranking – the best eyebrow pencils of 2024 Eyebrow pencil ranking – the best eyebrow pencils of 2024
4.09

Average Rating: 4.09

8574 votes

Authors' team

Emily Smith

Editor of the consumer ranking

Emily Smith

Emily is an experienced editor who has published nearly a thousand articles on various online portals. On the Consumer-Reports.Co.Uk website, she specializes in evaluating cosmetic products and accessories more >

Add Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *









Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment.